Hot topics close

'Shogun' Review: Rediscovering Japan

Shogun Review Rediscovering Japan
The FX remake of the classic mini-series is classed up, retuned for contemporary sensibilities and still an epic soap opera.

What to Watch

  • ‘Io Capitano’
  • ‘The Vince Staples Show’
  • ‘Madame Web’
  • ‘Bob Marley: One Love’
  • ‘Players’
  • ‘The Taste of Things’
  • U.S.
  • World
  • Business
  • Arts
  • Lifestyle
  • Opinion
  • Audio
  • Games
  • Cooking
  • Wirecutter
  • The Athletic

What to Watch

  • ‘Io Capitano’
  • ‘The Vince Staples Show’
  • ‘Madame Web’
  • ‘Bob Marley: One Love’
  • ‘Players’
  • ‘The Taste of Things’
SKIP ADVERTISEMENT
You have a preview view of this article while we are checking your access. When we have confirmed access, the full article content will load.

What to Watch

  • ‘Io Capitano’
  • ‘The Vince Staples Show’
  • ‘Madame Web’
  • ‘Bob Marley: One Love’
  • ‘Players’
  • ‘The Taste of Things’

Supported by

SKIP ADVERTISEMENT

‘Shogun’ Review: Rediscovering Japan

The FX remake of the classic mini-series is classed up, retuned for contemporary sensibilities and still an epic soap opera.

  • Share full article
A man on a white horse is flanked by flag bearers and spear carriers
Hiroyuki Sanada, center, stars as a cunning lord in feudal Japan in “Shogun,” adapted from the James Clavell best seller.Credit...Katie Yu/FX, via Associated Press
Mike Hale
Feb. 26, 2024

The new FX mini-series “Shogun” is getting a lot of credit simply for not being “Shogun,” the 1980 NBC mini-series also adapted from James Clavell’s best-selling novel about the last days of feudal Japan. But the new show stands and falls on the same terms as the old show: its success as an epic costumed soap opera. You can correct for wooden acting, dated production values and Eurocentrism, but you can’t really correct for the basic nature of the material.

And on those terms, this “Shogun” — which premieres Tuesday on FX and Hulu with two of its 10 episodes — is perfectly successful. It is sumptuously produced, mostly well acted and not excessively sentimental or sensational. If its story seems to stop and start a bit, there are reasons for that, which become clear in a satisfying and moving ending; if there are major characters who don’t stand up to scrutiny, there are others who come alive and hold your interest. It may not live up to its hype, and it may leave you wondering why so much time (more than a decade) and money needed to be spent reanimating Clavell’s tale. But it delivers.

Created by the husband-and-wife team of Justin Marks and Rachel Kondo, the FX “Shogun” is still the story of an English navigator, John Blackthorne, who arrives in Japan at the turn of the 17th century and becomes embroiled — to a startling degree — in the political, cultural and romantic life of the country. (Blackthorne, like most of the significant characters, is loosely based on a historical figure.)

Kondo and Marks have recalibrated the narrative, however, moving Blackthorne’s point of view down in the mix and elevating the roles of many of the Japanese characters, particularly Toda Mariko, the noblewoman who becomes Blackthorne’s translator and love interest, and Yoshii Toranaga, the lord who both protects and manipulates him.

That’s a notable change from the original “Shogun,” but 44 years down the road, it’s not as if the show should get a ton of credit — it’s an easy win. In the current global TV environment, the show’s emphasis on Japanese characters and language is welcome but not exceptional. (Tremendous effort reportedly also went into vetting the details of period costume and behavior; few viewers, even in Japan, are likely to know the difference, but what’s onscreen certainly looks credible to the rest of us.)

As the plot, busy yet not all that complicated, unwinds — Toranaga and his rival Ishido jockeying for power, with Blackthorne as a reluctant pawn; Blackthorne being alternately repulsed and seduced by his new surroundings — the real difference between the old and new shows has less to do with cultural enlightenment than with a higher level of tastefulness and technique. Though there is a multicultural dimension there, too: Marks and Kondo’s show is informed by the craftsmanship of classic Japanese samurai films, which were in turn heavily influenced by the attitudes and styles of Hollywood westerns and swashbucklers. This “Shogun” sits in a polyglot comfort zone.

We are having trouble retrieving the article content.

Please enable JavaScript in your browser settings.

Thank you for your patience while we verify access. If you are in Reader mode please exit and log into your Times account, or subscribe for all of The Times.

Thank you for your patience while we verify access.

Already a subscriber? Log in.

Want all of The Times? Subscribe.

SKIP ADVERTISEMENT
Similar shots
  • samurai travel tourism japaneseculture prank смешное shogun 일본 モニタリング 교토 goviral tiktok
  • 真田広之amp西岡徳馬お互いへの思いを語るSHOGUN 将軍来日大ヒット祈願イベント
News Archive
  • Madeleine Sami
    Madeleine Sami
    Ladyhawke and Madeleine Sami announce separation after more ...
    8 Jun 2023
    3
  • The Mandalorian
    The Mandalorian
    Mark Hamill Reacts To “Real Triumph” Of ‘The Mandalorian’ Season Finale’s Surprise Appearances
    18 Dec 2020
    4
  • The Santa Clause
    The Santa Clause
    Martin Short's Jack Frost (Almost) Makes The Santa Clause 3 Worth Watching
    21 Dec 2019
    2
  • Newstalk ZB
    Newstalk ZB
    Watch Live: Christoper Luxon in studio with Mike Hosking
    10 Jun 2024
    22
  • Jay Leno
    Jay Leno
    Jay Leno Seriously Burned From Gasoline Fire: ‘Need a Week or Two to Get Back on My Feet’
    15 Nov 2022
    4
This week's most popular shots